Characterization: Direct vs. Indirect Characterization, STEAL and Short Story Examples
Spot direct and indirect characterization in a short story, sort clues with the STEAL method, tell static from dynamic and round from flat characters, and write a claim-evidence-explanation paragraph. Every quotation links to its paragraph.
By Hommer Zhao, Founder & General Manager
Last updated
In short: characterization is how an author reveals what a character is like. In direct characterization the narrator tells you a trait outright (“The trouble with him was that he was without imagination”). In indirect characterization the author shows the trait through what the character says, thinks, does and looks like, and how others react, and you infer it. Teachers often use the acronym STEAL for those indirect clues. Every quotation below is copied word for word from a complete story on this site and links to the exact paragraph, so you can check it in context.
| Direct characterization | Indirect characterization | |
|---|---|---|
| Who tells the reader | The narrator (or another character) states the trait | Nobody names it; the evidence implies it |
| How it appears | A label or summary: “proud”, “gentle”, “a failure in art” | Speech, thoughts, effect on others, actions, looks (STEAL) |
| Example from this site | “Romance at short notice was her speciality.” (The Open Window, paragraph 29) | “When he frowned she trembled, but loved him.” (Désirée’s Baby, paragraph 17) |
| What the reader does | Accepts the label, or questions who is giving it | Collects clues and draws a conclusion |
On a phone, swipe the table sideways to see all columns.
What Is Characterization? Definition and Meaning
Characterization is the set of methods an author uses to create a character and reveal their personality, motives and values. It covers both what the text says about a character and what it lets you work out for yourself. (Pronounced KAIR-ik-tuh-ruh-ZAY-shun; British spelling: characterisation.)
As a reader, you meet characterization every time you form an opinion about someone in a story. The skill in an English class is to explain where that opinion came from: which words, which paragraph, which method. That is why this guide is written from the reader’s side. If you want to build characters in your own fiction, the writer’s side is covered in Creating Compelling Characters.
What Is Direct Characterization? Definition and Examples
Direct characterization is when the text tells you a character’s trait in plain words. It is quick and clear, and it often comes from the narrator. Four examples from stories on this site:
- •To Build a Fire: “The trouble with him was that he was without imagination.” London’s narrator names the man’s fatal flaw before the cold does anything to him (paragraph 3).
- •The Open Window: Vera is introduced as “a very self-possessed young lady of fifteen” (paragraph 1), and the last line sums her up: “Romance at short notice was her speciality.” (paragraph 29).
- •Désirée’s Baby: Chopin tells us outright that marriage “had softened Armand Aubigny's imperious and exacting nature greatly” and calls his wife “the gentle Désirée” (paragraph 17).
- •Sredni Vashtar: in one clause Saki dismisses a minor character: “The doctor was silky and effete, and counted for little” (paragraph 1).
Check who is speaking. Direct characterization is only as trustworthy as its source. When Montresor says of his victim, “He had a weak point—this Fortunato” (The Cask of Amontillado, paragraph 3), that is a direct statement, but it comes from a narrator planning a murder. In an essay, treat it as Montresor’s judgment, not a neutral fact.
What Is Indirect Characterization? Definition and Examples
Indirect characterization is when the author shows a trait without naming it, and you infer it from evidence. It asks more of the reader, which is why stories rely on it so heavily and why exam questions so often ask about it.
Two short examples:
- •In The Necklace, M. Loisel lifts the lid of the soup and says “Ah, the good pot-au-feu! I don’t know anything better than that,” while Mathilde “thought of dainty dinners, of shining silverware” (paragraph 4). Maupassant never says that he is content and she is not; one sentence of speech and one of thought show it.
- •In The Story of an Hour, nobody tells us that Mrs. Mallard felt trapped in her marriage. Instead, alone in her room, she keeps whispering “Free! Body and soul free!” (paragraph 14).
A good inference names the trait and points to the words that support it. “Mathilde is materialistic” is a guess until you add “because, faced with a plain family supper, she imagines silverware and trout”.
Direct vs. Indirect Characterization: Key Differences
- •Telling vs. showing. Direct characterization tells; indirect characterization shows. Most stories use both.
- •Speed vs. depth. A direct label saves time, which is useful for minor characters (Saki’s doctor gets a single clause). Indirect evidence takes longer but makes a trait feel earned.
- •Certainty vs. interpretation. A direct statement gives you the trait; indirect evidence can support more than one reading, which is what makes it good essay material.
- •Agreement or tension. The two methods can agree or clash. When a character’s actions contradict what the narrator says about them, that gap is usually the point of the story.
Both Methods in One Character: Behrman in The Last Leaf
O. Henry characterizes the old painter Behrman directly first: “Behrman was a failure in art.” A few lines later he is “a fierce little old man, who scoffed terribly at softness in any one” (paragraph 30). His speech seems to confirm the label: he “yelled” at Sue, “You are just like a woman!”, yet in the same speech he says “dis is not any blace in which one so goot as Miss Yohnsy shall lie sick” (paragraph 35).
The final paragraph then reveals his decisive action indirectly, through objects: “a lantern, still lighted, and a ladder that had been dragged from its place, and some scattered brushes” (paragraph 55). The direct labels (“failure”, “scoffed … at softness”) are overturned by the indirect evidence. He painted his masterpiece after all, and his softness killed him. Comparing the two methods is the clearest way into this story’s ending.
STEAL: The 5 Methods of Indirect Characterization
STEAL is a classroom acronym for the five kinds of indirect evidence: Speech, Thoughts, Effect on others, Actions and Looks. It is a reading checklist, not a rule that every story uses all five. The University of Minnesota’s open textbook chapter on characterization uses the same acronym. Be careful with terms: that chapter labels the STEAL methods direct characterization and narrator commentary indirect, the reverse of the usage on this page and in most school courses. If your teacher or textbook uses the reversed terms, follow theirs and keep the method the same.
| Letter | Question to ask | Example from this site | What it suggests |
|---|---|---|---|
| S: Speech | What does the character say, and how? | “Gott! dis is not any blace in which one so goot as Miss Yohnsy shall lie sick.” (The Last Leaf, paragraph 35) | Behrman’s gruffness hides real tenderness for Johnsy |
| T: Thoughts | What does the character think or feel privately? | “There would be no one to live for her during those coming years; she would live for herself.” (The Story of an Hour, paragraph 12) | Mrs. Mallard has longed for independence |
| E: Effect on others | How do other characters react to them? | “When he frowned she trembled, but loved him.” (Désirée’s Baby, paragraph 17) | Armand dominates the household; Désirée depends on his mood |
| A: Actions | What does the character do? | “She washed the dishes, using her rosy nails on the greasy pots and pans.” (The Necklace, paragraph 100) | Mathilde, once too proud for her home, now accepts hard work |
| L: Looks | What do appearance and clothing suggest? | “The man wore motley.” (The Cask of Amontillado, paragraph 4) | Fortunato is dressed as a fool on the night he is fooled |
On a phone, swipe the table sideways to see all columns. The “What it suggests” column is an interpretation; the quotation is the evidence.
S: Speech in Characterization
How much speech you have to work with varies a lot. We counted the paragraphs that contain quotation marks (mostly dialogue) in ten stories on this site: 1 of 40 in To Build a Fire, 5 of 21 in The Story of an Hour, 32 of 55 in The Last Leaf, 21 of 29 in The Open Window and 64 of 89 in The Cask of Amontillado (full table below). In a story with almost no dialogue, such as To Build a Fire, you will rely on direct statements, thoughts and actions instead.
Listen for word choice, accent, tone and what a character avoids saying. Behrman’s German-accented English and shouted insults sit side by side with “one so goot as Miss Yohnsy”. In The Open Window, Vera invents a horror story about the visitor “calmly” (paragraph 28); her calm speech in the middle of the chaos she has caused is the clue to her character.
T: Thoughts in Characterization
Thoughts show the gap between a character’s public and private self. Mrs. Mallard grieves in front of her family, but alone her thoughts run to “a long procession of years to come that would belong to her absolutely” (paragraph 11). Thoughts are only available when the narration can enter a character’s mind, so they connect to point of view.
E: Effect on Others in Characterization
How people respond to a character is evidence about that character. Désirée trembles at Armand’s frown. In Sredni Vashtar, the boy’s reaction to his guardian characterizes her: “Conradin hated her with a desperate sincerity which he was perfectly able to mask” (paragraph 2). The same sentence characterizes Conradin too: he can hide what he feels.
A: Actions in Characterization
Actions are often the strongest evidence because they cost the character something. After the necklace is lost, Mathilde “took her part, moreover, all on a sudden, with heroism. That dreadful debt must be paid. She would pay it.” (paragraph 99). In The Gift of the Magi, Della’s decision is a single question: “Will you buy my hair?” (paragraph 12).
L: Looks in Characterization
Appearance, clothing and setting can all carry character. Fortunato “had on a tight-fitting parti-striped dress, and his head was surmounted by the conical cap and bells” (paragraph 4), the costume of a jester. At the end of The Story of an Hour, “There was a feverish triumph in her eyes, and she carried herself unwittingly like a goddess of Victory” (paragraph 18): her body shows what she would never say aloud.
Static vs. Dynamic Characters: Examples
A dynamic character changes in an important way during the story; a static character stays essentially the same. Characterization is how you prove which is which: compare the evidence early and late in the story.
- •Dynamic: Soapy in The Cop and the Anthem. He spends the story trying to get arrested, until church music “wrought a sudden and wonderful change in his soul” (paragraph 42) and he resolves, “He would pull himself out of the mire” (paragraph 43). The irony is that a policeman takes him in at the very moment he changes (paragraphs 44–47), and the next morning he gets “Three months on the Island” (paragraph 48).
- •Dynamic: Mathilde in The Necklace. Compare her at the start, when “She suffered ceaselessly, feeling herself born for all the delicacies and all the luxuries” (paragraph 3), with the woman washing greasy pots during the years of repayment (paragraph 100); “this life lasted ten years” (paragraph 103).
- •Static: Vera in The Open Window. She is “self-possessed” in the first paragraph and still inventing stories in the last. The story does not need her to change; it needs her to stay perfectly in control.
- •Static: Montresor in The Cask of Amontillado. His purpose in the first line, “I vowed revenge” (paragraph 1), never wavers.
Static does not mean badly written. Whether a character is the protagonist or antagonist is a separate question, covered in Protagonist and Antagonist.
Round vs. Flat Characters: Examples
The terms come from E. M. Forster’s Aspects of the Novel (1927). A round character is complex, with mixed motives and inner conflict; a flat character is built around one trait or function.
- •Round: Sylvia in A White Heron. At the climax she is pulled two ways at once: “Has she been nine years growing, and now, when the great world for the first time puts out a hand to her, must she thrust it aside for a bird’s sake?” (paragraph 40). She wants the hunter’s approval and money, yet she loves the heron and the woods, and the story makes both pulls believable. Several traits in real conflict, revealed through her thoughts, are the evidence for calling her round.
- •Round: Mrs. Mallard. She grieves and rejoices in the same hour: “And yet she had loved him — sometimes. Often she had not.” (paragraph 13).
- •Flat: Madame Sofronie in The Gift of the Magi. She exists to buy Della’s hair and gets one line of description: “Madame, large, too white, chilly, hardly looked the “Sofronie.”” (paragraph 11).
- •Flat: the doctor in Sredni Vashtar, “silky and effete”, who “counted for little” (paragraph 1).
Short stories have little room, so most minor characters are flat by design. Round/flat and static/dynamic are separate scales: whether a character counts as round is an interpretation you support with evidence, not a fixed label.
How to Analyze Characterization in a Short Story
Use these steps for a class discussion, a reading log or an essay plan. For analyzing a whole story (plot, setting, theme), see How to Analyze a Short Story.
For a class activity: give each group one STEAL letter and one story, ask them to find the strongest quotation for that letter in ten minutes, then put the five quotations side by side on the board and agree on a single trait word. As an exit ticket, each student writes one claim sentence with a paragraph number.
STEAL Chart: Characterization Worksheet Template
Copy this chart into your notes, or print the page. Fill in one row per method; leave a row blank if the story gives no evidence of that kind (that absence can be worth noticing too). The first row is filled in as an example.
| STEAL method | Quotation (with paragraph number) | What it reveals about the character |
|---|---|---|
| Speech (example) | “Gott! dis is not any blace in which one so goot as Miss Yohnsy shall lie sick.” (The Last Leaf, paragraph 35) | Behrman is gruff, but he cares about Johnsy |
| Speech | ||
| Thoughts | ||
| Effect on others | ||
| Actions | ||
| Looks | ||
| Direct statement (if any) |
On a phone, swipe the table sideways to see all columns. Every story page on this site numbers its paragraphs, so you can link or cite each quotation exactly.
How to Write a Characterization Analysis Paragraph (Claim, Evidence, Explanation)
A characterization paragraph needs three parts:
Template: In [story], [author] uses [direct/indirect: method] to show that [character] is [trait]. When [context], [quotation] (paragraph [N]). This [word or detail] suggests [inference], which matters because [link to theme or ending].
Example paragraph (The Necklace):
In “The Necklace,” Guy de Maupassant uses direct characterization and then actions to show that Mathilde Loisel changes from a woman ashamed of her modest life into one who can endure real hardship. At the start the narrator tells us, “She suffered ceaselessly, feeling herself born for all the delicacies and all the luxuries” (paragraph 3); even worn-out chairs and ugly curtains “tortured her”. After the necklace is lost, her actions say the opposite: “She washed the dishes, using her rosy nails on the greasy pots and pans” (paragraph 100). Setting her “rosy nails”, a sign of the delicate life she imagined, against “greasy pots” shows that life being worn away by work. Because the change is shown through actions rather than announced, the ending feels crueler: her sacrifice was real, but the necklace was not.
For a full worked analysis of The Story of an Hour (character, conflict, theme), see the worksheet in How to Analyze a Short Story.
Characterization, Archetypes and Stereotypes
An archetype is a character pattern that recurs across many stories (the trickster, the mentor, the innocent). A stereotype is a flat pattern that replaces evidence with an assumption about a group. Characterization is what turns a pattern into a particular person: Vera in The Open Window fits the trickster pattern, but her calm speech and her invented details are what make her Vera. In analysis, name the archetype if it helps, then spend your sentences on the specific evidence.
Why Authors Use Characterization
- •To make characters believable. Specific speech and actions make a person on the page feel real.
- •To create conflict. Traits drive choices: the man’s lack of imagination in To Build a Fire is what leads him to ignore the danger.
- •To set up the ending. Twist endings often depend on characterization: Vera’s self-possession and Behrman’s hidden softness are planted before they pay off.
- •To carry the theme. What happens to a character because of who they are is often what a story is about.
Using Indirect Characterization in Your Own Writing
If you are writing a story rather than analyzing one, turn STEAL around: instead of labeling a character “selfish” or “brave”, choose one line of speech, one private thought and one action that would make a reader reach that word on their own. Keep at least one direct statement for minor characters, as Saki does with the doctor. For the full method (giving a character a want and an obstacle, choosing a telling detail, writing dialogue and building an arc), see Creating Compelling Characters, and practise with its 500-word character sketch exercise.
Characterization Examples in Our Short Stories
Editorial selection dated November 22, 2026. This index links one direct and one indirect passage for a character in stories published on this site. They are interpretations, not a complete survey. Numbers are paragraph numbers and link to the passage.
| Story | Character | Direct passage | Indirect passage (STEAL) |
|---|---|---|---|
| The Last Leaf | Behrman | 30 | 35 speech, 55 actions |
| The Open Window | Vera | 1, 29 | 28 speech |
| Désirée’s Baby | Armand | 17 | 17 effect on others |
| To Build a Fire | The man | 3 | 6 the dog as a foil |
| The Cask of Amontillado | Fortunato | 3 (Montresor’s view) | 4 looks |
| The Story of an Hour | Mrs. Mallard | 7 (“a fair, calm face, whose lines bespoke repression”) | 12 thoughts, 18 looks |
| The Necklace | Mathilde | 3 | 4 thoughts, 100 actions |
| Sredni Vashtar | Mrs. de Ropp | 1 | 2 effect on others |
| A White Heron | Sylvia | 3 (“Afraid of folks”, as others describe her) | 40 thoughts |
| The Cop and the Anthem | Soapy | 42 | 43 thoughts |
On a phone, swipe the table sideways to see all columns.
Paragraphs containing quotation marks, by story. We counted these on November 22, 2026, using the full texts as published on this site that day. A paragraph counts if it contains any straight or curly double quotation mark. Share = paragraphs with quotation marks ÷ all paragraphs, rounded to one decimal place. Most of these paragraphs are dialogue, but not all: in The Story of an Hour, paragraph 2 quotes a single word from a newspaper list. The ten stories are the ones in the index above, not a random sample, so use the counts only as a rough guide to how much Speech evidence you are likely to find.
| Story | Paragraphs | Paragraphs with quotation marks | Share |
|---|---|---|---|
| To Build a Fire | 40 | 1 | 2.5% |
| The Story of an Hour | 21 | 5 | 23.8% |
| A White Heron | 41 | 15 | 36.6% |
| The Cop and the Anthem | 48 | 19 | 39.6% |
| The Necklace | 128 | 52 | 40.6% |
| Désirée’s Baby | 49 | 21 | 42.9% |
| Sredni Vashtar | 20 | 10 | 50.0% |
| The Last Leaf | 55 | 32 | 58.2% |
| The Open Window | 29 | 21 | 72.4% |
| The Cask of Amontillado | 89 | 64 | 71.9% |
Characterization FAQ
What is characterization in simple terms?
It is how a story shows you what a character is like: either by telling you (direct) or by giving you clues to work out (indirect).
What is the difference between direct and indirect characterization?
Direct characterization states a trait (“he was without imagination”). Indirect characterization shows it through speech, thoughts, effect on others, actions or looks, and leaves the conclusion to you.
What does STEAL stand for in characterization?
Speech, Thoughts, Effect on others, Actions and Looks: the five kinds of evidence for indirect characterization.
Is characterization a literary device?
It is usually listed among literary devices or elements of fiction. Strictly it is a set of techniques (description, dialogue, action and so on) used for one purpose: revealing character.
Can a story use only indirect characterization?
It is possible, but rare; most stories mix both methods. The Story of an Hour comes close on the question that matters most: the narrator describes Mrs. Mallard’s face (paragraph 7) but never states that she felt trapped in her marriage. That comes through her thoughts and appearance.
Is a character’s name a form of characterization?
It can be. The narrator of The Gift of the Magi notes that the “Dillingham” on Jim’s card was added “during a former period of prosperity” (paragraph 4), so a name can hint at status and change. Treat a name as a clue to support with other evidence, not as proof by itself.