Skip to main content
All Techniques

Unreliable Narrator in Short Stories

Browse our curated collection of short stories featuring unreliable narrator with literary analysis and discussion guides.

5 stories available

What is an unreliable narrator?

An unreliable narrator is a narrator whose account of events the reader cannot fully trust. The narrator may be lying, deceiving themselves, misunderstanding what they see, or describing a mind under strain. Most unreliable narrators speak in the first person, but a close third-person narration can also mislead by following one character’s perceptions.

The technique opens a gap between what the narrator tells us and what the story lets us infer. Reading an unreliable narrator means collecting evidence for that gap: contradictions, details the narrator reports without understanding, and moments where the narrator protests too much. The five examples below come from complete stories on this site, with paragraph numbers you can check.

The narrator who insists on their sanity

The narrator argues for their own reliability, and the argument itself becomes the evidence against them.

Example — The Tell-Tale Heart by Edgar Allan Poe: The first lines set up the contest: “nervous -- very, very dreadfully nervous I had been and am; but why will you say that I am mad?” (paragraph 1). The narrator offers his patience and cunning as proof of sanity, and ends by shrieking a confession to the police (paragraph 18).

The calm avenger

A controlled, reasonable voice describes cruelty without remorse, so the reader must judge what the narrator will not.

Example — The Cask of Amontillado by Edgar Allan Poe: Montresor never names the “thousand injuries” or the insult he claims to avenge (paragraph 1). He closes fifty years later with “In pace requiescat!” (paragraph 89), leaving the reader to weigh his motive and his peace of mind.

The diarist whose perception shifts

A private record lets the reader watch perception change entry by entry, while the narrator does not see the change.

Example — The Yellow Wallpaper by Charlotte Perkins Gilman: The narrator first sees in the pattern “a woman stooping down and creeping about” (paragraph 122) and at the end declares, “I've got out at last” (paragraph 256). Her account stays sincere, but the reader sees how confinement has changed it.

The narrator who disclaims belief

The narrator announces in advance that the story will be hard to believe, which invites the reader to test it.

Example — The Black Cat by Edgar Allan Poe: “I neither expect nor solicit belief. Mad indeed would I be to expect it” (paragraph 1). He blames “the Fiend Intemperance” and “the spirit of PERVERSENESS” for what follows, and the reader has to decide how much of that account to accept.

The misleading close third person

A third-person narrator follows one character so closely that the character’s perceptions are presented as events.

Example — An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge by Ambrose Bierce: Part III reports Farquhar’s escape as fact: his senses are “preternaturally keen and alert” (paragraph 23). The final sentence corrects it: “Peyton Farquhar was dead” (paragraph 40). The narration was reliable about his perceptions, not about what happened.

Writing an unreliable narrator

Techniques

  • Establish trust first. Let the reader settle into the voice before the cracks show.
  • Plant contradictions. The narrator says one thing and describes another: “I wasn’t jealous at all,” followed by a paragraph about every detail of a rival’s success.
  • Use other characters as counterweights. If the narrator describes a pleasant conversation but the other person leaves in tears, the reader starts to question.
  • Control the information gap. Know what actually happened, and map it beside the narrator’s version.
  • Vary the degree of unreliability. A narrator is most effective when mostly reliable and wrong about the things that matter most to them.

The reveal

At some point the reader must see the unreliability. It can grow gradually, as contradictions pile up, or arrive at once, as in Bierce’s final paragraph. After the reveal, resist explaining the “true” version of every event; let the reader reread and reinterpret.

Exercise

Write a 1,000-word first-person story about an event from the narrator’s past. The narrator should believe they behaved well, but the details they include should suggest otherwise. Do not let the narrator admit it.

Frequently asked questions

What is an unreliable narrator in simple terms?

It is a narrator you cannot fully trust. The story gives you enough evidence to notice that the narrator is lying, mistaken, biased, or not seeing clearly.

What are the types of unreliable narrator?

Common types are the liar, the self-deceiver, the naive narrator who does not understand what they see, and the narrator whose perception is distorted by illness, trauma, or obsession. A close third-person narration can also mislead, as in “An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge.”

How do you spot an unreliable narrator?

Look for contradictions between what the narrator claims and what they describe, for other characters reacting in ways the narrator does not explain, and for a narrator who defends themselves before anyone has accused them.

Is the narrator of The Tell-Tale Heart unreliable?

Yes. He insists he is not mad and offers his careful planning as proof, but his account includes a sound that no one else hears and ends in a confession he cannot stop himself from making.

Stories that use unreliable narrator (5)

“True! -- nervous -- very, very dreadfully nervous I had been and am; but why will you say that I am mad? The disease had...”
Edgar Allan Poe2,146 wordsIntermediate

The Tell-Tale Heart

An unnamed narrator insists upon their sanity while describing the methodical killing of an old man. Driven mad by the old man's "vulture eye," the narrator commits the act with precision, dismembers the body, and hides it beneath the floorboards. When police arrive, the narrator's guilt manifests as an unbearable phantom heartbeat, leading to a confession.

Gothic HorrorPsychological FictionUnreliable NarratorGothic Atmosphere
“The thousand injuries of Fortunato I had borne as I best could, but when he ventured upon insult I vowed revenge....”
Edgar Allan Poe2,331 wordsIntermediate

The Cask of Amontillado

Montresor, nursing a grudge over an unspecified insult, lures his acquaintance Fortunato deep into underground catacombs during carnival season under the pretense of evaluating a rare cask of Amontillado sherry. Exploiting Fortunato's pride as a wine connoisseur and his drunken state, Montresor chains him inside a narrow recess and methodically walls him in with stone and mortar, entombing him alive. Fifty years later, Montresor recounts the crime, and the remains have never been found.

Gothic HorrorMysteryUnreliable NarratorIrony
“A man stood upon a railroad bridge in northern Alabama, looking down into the swift water twenty feet below....”
Ambrose Bierce3,764 wordsAdvanced

An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge

Peyton Farquhar, a Confederate sympathizer, stands on the Owl Creek bridge about to be hanged by Union soldiers. A flashback reveals he was tricked by a disguised Federal scout into attempting to burn the bridge. At the moment of execution, Farquhar appears to escape: the rope breaks, he plunges into the creek, evades gunfire, and treks through the wilderness toward home. Just as he reaches his wife, the narrative reveals the entire escape was a dying hallucination — Farquhar hangs dead from the bridge, his neck broken.

Literary FictionPsychological FictionUnreliable NarratorStream of Consciousness
“It is very seldom that mere ordinary people like John and myself secure ancestral halls for the summer. A colonial mans...”
Charlotte Perkins Gilman6,140 wordsAdvanced

The Yellow Wallpaper

A woman suffering from what her physician husband John calls a 'temporary nervous depression' is confined for a summer to an upstairs room and forbidden to work or write. Denied any outlet, she becomes fixated on the room's sickly yellow wallpaper. In secret journal entries she begins to see a woman trapped and creeping behind the pattern, and gradually identifies with her. By the end she has torn the paper from the walls to 'free' the trapped woman - and, creeping around the locked room, has slipped entirely into madness.

Literary FictionPsychological FictionUnreliable NarratorSymbolism
“For the most wild, yet most homely narrative which I am about to pen, I neither expect nor solicit belief....”
Edgar Allan Poe3,915 wordsAdvanced

The Black Cat

A once gentle, animal-loving man descends into alcoholism and cruelty. He mutilates and then hangs his beloved black cat, Pluto; that night his house burns, leaving the image of a hanged cat scorched on a wall. He takes in a second, similar cat whose white patch, he claims, grows into the shape of a gallows, and his hatred of it deepens. When his wife stops his axe blow at the animal, he pulls free and buries the blade in her brain, then walls her corpse in the cellar. Confident he is safe, he raps on the wall for the visiting police - and a wailing cry answers from within: he has entombed the cat alive with the body, and its voice sends him to the gallows.

Gothic HorrorPsychological FictionUnreliable NarratorSymbolism